Skip to main content

Can investors invoke so-called force majeure clauses to get out deals? Expect some to start trying

Event organizers were the first to be hit hard. As fear of the spread of Covid-19 began to sweep cities and countries around the world last month, one by one, large conferences with long uninterrupted histories —  Mobile World Congress, South by Southwest — began reluctantly pulling the plug on their plans. It wasn’t just a shock for these organizations; it will cost them and the vendors with which they work and surrounding service providers like hotels and car services millions of dollars in lost revenue.

Little wonder that many of those involved in the planning of such events are now testing the power of force majeure clauses, which are a typical provision in contracts that excuses a party’s performance of its obligations when confronted with circumstances beyond its control.

Yet they won’t be alone for long. With every passing day, it’s become clear that event organizers were just the proverbial canaries in the coal mine. As the world shuts down and people are urged to quarantine themselves, it seems no one will be spared from Covid-19 — not from its economic impact anyway. And that include startups and venture capital firms. Indeed, as the global markets tank, many of the institutions that fuel the venture capital industry are seeing their assets hammered. At some point, money flow could well become a problem.

Nate Cooper, a lawyer with Cooley’s 1100-attorney-strong firm, says it’s “mostly just clients right now, coming to us, anticipating this or that,” but he also says that because the “impact to the financial markets has obviously been significant,” there exists the “potential for disagreement about whether it’s enough to force changes to a financing agreement or suspend the timing of payment.”

Whether they can rely on force majeure clauses is less certain. Even for conference organizers or participants, he says, the “devil is in the details.” For one thing, most force majeure clauses enumerate as applicable acts of God or government actions, but there’s no precedent for whether a pandemic qualifies as an “act of God” unlike flash floods, earthquakes, and other natural disasters, where there is precedent.

Further, while some governments, as in Italy, have banned outright public gatherings, other governments are merely strongly “advising” populations not to gather in numbers. “Certainly, depending on the specific provision, there can be a lot of gray,” says Cooper.

As it pertains the startup industry, things aren’t bubbling up quite yet but Cooper notes you could “see a situation where you’re raising a round or it closed, and the investors no longer like the deal,” or where the “acquisition of capital is necessary to perform a contract, and there are concerns about that regarding the timing.”

Absent a market turnaround, we’ll invariably see more of the same soon. When we do, Cooper hopes people will try diplomacy first.

“You have the legal side of things, and the human side, and the more persuasive is the human side,” he says. “Everybody recognizes we’re in uncharted territory; everyone needs to be flexible.”

If you’re curious to learn more, Cooley is shooting out a client alert about the “applicability of force majeure and related doctrines in response to COVID-19” tomorrow to help its business customers understand better whether they can use it — and what its limitations are. We got a sneak peek and it’s worth a read, so we’ll link to it when it’s live.

For anyone wondering in the meantime if it might rescue them from either a financing round or a commitment to a venture fund, it seems possible but unlikely.

As says one section of the alert, “[I]n the aftermath of the 2008 financial crises, courts consistently concluded that market forces do not count as force majeure. While there were exceptions to this, it was generally because the specific force majeure clause contained nonstandard language (such as a reference to a ‘change in economic conditions’) that might apply to financial turmoil.”

The general rule, suggests the law firm, is that a crummy market — no matter how harrowing — doesn’t qualify as an unforeseeable circumstance that prevents someone from fulfilling a contract — even if what precipitated it was as hard as this one to imagine.



from TechCrunch https://ift.tt/2xMK137

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

How To Play Doom – And More – On An NES

Doom was a breakthrough game for its time, and became so popular that now it’s essentially the “Banana For Scale” of hardware hacking. Doom has been ported to countless devices, most of which have enough processing ability to run the game natively. Recently, this lineup of Doom-compatible devices expanded to include the NES even though the system definitely doesn’t have enough capability to run it without special help. And if you want your own Doom NES cartridge, this video will show you how to build it . We featured the original build from [TheRasteri] a while back which goes into details about how it’s possible to run such a resource-intensive game on a comparatively weak system. You just have to enter the cheat code “RASPI”. After all the heavy lifting is done, it’s time to put it into a realistic-looking cartridge. To get everything to fit in the donor cartridge, first the ICs in the cartridge were removed (except the lockout IC) and replaced with custom ROM chips. Some modifica...

Try NopSCADlib for your Next OpenSCAD Project

Most readers of this site are familiar by now with the OpenSCAD 3D modeling software, where you can write code to create 3D models. You may have even used OpenSCAD to output some STL files for your 3D printer. But for years now, [nophead] has been pushing OpenSCAD further than most, creating some complex utility and parts libraries to help with modeling, and a suite of Python scripts that generate printable STLs, laser-ready DXFs, bills of material, and human-readable assembly instructions complete with PNG imagery of exploded-view sub-assemblies. Recently [nophead] tidied all of this OpenSCAD infrastructure up and released it on GitHub as NopSCADlib . You can find out more by browsing through the example projects and README file in the repository, and by reading the announcement blog post on the HydraRaptor blog . Some functionality highlights include: a large parts library full of motors, buttons, smooth rod, et cetera many utility functions to help with chamfers, fillets, precis...

The Newbie’s Guide To JTAG

Do you even snarf? If not, it might be because you haven’t mastered the basics of JTAG and learned how to dump, or snarf, the firmware of an embedded device. This JTAG primer will get you up to snuff on snarfing, and help you build your reverse engineering skills. Whatever your motivation for diving into reverse engineering devices with microcontrollers, JTAG skills are a must, and [Sergio Prado]’s guide will get you going. He starts with a description and brief history of the Joint Test Action Group interface, from its humble beginnings as a PCB testing standard to the de facto standard for testing, debugging, and flashing firmware onto devices. He covers how to locate the JTAG pads – even when they’ve been purposely obfuscated – including the use of brute-force tools like the JTAGulator . Once you’ve got a connection, his tutorial helps you find the firmware in flash memory and snarf it up to a file for inspection, modification, or whatever else you have planned. We always apprec...